Telling You How I Would Feel: Emotional Communication and Uncertainty in Trust
Abstract
Trust requires engaging with uncertainty about others’ reciprocity. Emotional communication may shape how people perceive and evaluate this uncertainty, yet many social environments constrain emotional expression. This paper examines whether communicating anticipated feelings affects willingness to trust. It considers three channels using the incentivized belief hedge method: belief, ambiguity aversion, and ambiguity-generated insensitivity. In a preregistered modified trust game, 350 U.S.-based Prolific participants are randomly assigned to one of four conditions: no message, happy message, disappointed message, or a choice between the two. Overall, emotional communication modestly increases expected returns but does not significantly affect trust or actual returns. Its effects on attitudes vary by emotion: happiness message increases ambiguity seeking, while disappointment message reduces a-insensitivity. These findings show that structured anticipated-emotion messages reshape how people perceive and evaluate uncertainty surrounding trust.